Indictment of Former Head of Presidential Guard for Torture During 2010 Election is Good Oportunity to Look Closer at Widespread State-Sponsored Violence Which Brought Conde to Power

Excerpt from a November 29, 2010 statement by Human Rights Watch

“The Human Rights Watch investigation in Guinea showed that members of the security forces used ethnic slurs against members of the Peuhl ethnic group, collaborated with civilian mobs from ethnic groups that largely supported Condé, and in several cases looted and stole property from people who were perceived to have supported Diallo. Although the security forces may have sought to quell the violence that seized the cities of Conakry, Dalaba, and Labé, they failed to provide equal protection to all Guineans, Human Rights Watch said.

Behaving more as predators than protectors, security force members in Guinea have for decades been allowed to get away with abuses including extortion, banditry, theft, kidnapping, racketeering, and excessive use of lethal force, with no apparent fear of being held accountable. Successive authoritarian heads of state have used the security services for partisan ends to repress political opponents, influence the outcome of elections, and intimidate the judiciary.”
The full statement can be found here.
No state-sponsored human rights abuser has ever gotten what he deserved for crimes committed against fellow citizens of Guinea.  Here is yet another example.  Aboubacar Sidiki Camara, nicknamed “De Gaulle,” former head of the presidential guard was indicted for crimes of torture against supporters ofl candidate, Cellou Dalein Diallo, in the final round of the presidential election 2010.  In Guinea, indictments are handed down and the perpetrators never go to trial.
But, Camara’s indictment is a good opportunity to learn more about how election violence was used to intimidate and disenfranchise Diallo supporters, largely of the Peul ethnicity.
Below are three articles:
-an August 1, 2013, statement from international human rights group, FIDH, and its member organization, the Guinean human rights group, OGDH, about Camara’s indictment
-second, an October 25, 2010, statement from Amnesty International condemning the “excessive force”  used by Guinean forces during the election
-lastly, a November 5, 2010, statement by Human Rights Watch imploring the interim government of Sekouba Konate to restrain Guinean forces’ attacks on civilians
The bottom line is that the excessive violence committed by the state took place throughout the campaign, election, and post-election, a period of six months.  The violence included summary executions, raw brutality, and torture.  The victims were largely Peuls
FIDH and its member organization in Guinea, OGDH, announce the indictment of commander Aboubacar Sidiki Camara said “De Gaulle”, former head of the presidential guard, for his alleged responsibility for acts of torture committed in Conakry in October 2010 . FIDH and OGDH, behind this procedure and civil parties along with 17 victims in this case, welcome this important step in this judicial inquiry suggests holding a trial.
Guinea: Indictment of the former head of the presidential guard in the case of torture in 2010
July 31, 2013, the judge in charge of the judicial investigation called the “Case torture October 2010” was formally charged and placed in custody commander Aboubacar Sidiki Camara said “De Gaulle,” former head of the presidential guard during the transition period led by Sékouba KONATÉ for his alleged responsibility for acts of torture and inhuman and degrading treatment in October 2010 in a district of Conakry. ”  Justice finally plays its role and place authors suspects face the consequences of their actions. We now need justice applies to all perpetrators of violations of human rights in Guinea, including recent violence in the region NZérékoré and in clashes between security forces and protesters during political marches that took place since the beginning of the year. Justice has been entered, it must go through  , “said Thierno Sow, president of the OGDH. FIDH and had OGDH alongside 17 torture victims, filed a complaint on May 18 2012 against the Commander Sékou Resco Camara, General Nouhou Thiam, former Chief of Staff and Commander Aboubacar Sidiki “De Gaulle” Camara, former head of the presidential guard. Quickly following the complaint of the FIDH and OGDH before the court of first instance Dixinn (Conakry II), the prosecutor had opened an investigation May 29, 2012 , including “unlawful arrest, false imprisonment, intentional assault, abuse of authority, crimes committed in the exercise of his functions “that had identified the alleged command responsibility Sékou Resco Camara and General Nouhou Thiam, both charged respectively on 14 and 25 February in 2013 . In October 2010, according to information submitted to the court, the elements of the bodyguard of the Acting Chairman of the transition were arbitrarily arrested and detained several people and were subjected to torture in the presence and following the instructions Mr. Sékou Resco Camara, General Nouhou Thiam, and Commandant Aboubacar Sidiki Camara said “De Gaulle”. These crimes committed by those in charge of public authority were held on the sidelines of the presidential campaign for the second round and not directly related to it. However, these violations remain symptomatic arbitrary practices, legacies of political violence and a half-century of impunity in Guinea. ”  This new indictment shows that advance education and that a trial is no longer a far for victims of political violence in Guinea hypothesis  , “said Mr. Martin Pradel, lawyer Legal Action Group FIDH and victims. ”  This is the fourth charge of a senior this year for serious violations of human rights perpetrated in 2009 and 2010, it shows that we can not commit such acts with impunity  , “he added. FIDH and OGDH call the Guinean authorities to take all necessary measures to ensure the proper administration of justice, ensuring the safety of its players and especially magistrates in charge of investigations into serious violations of human Man after this series of charges, including that of commander PIVI Claude “Coplan” , the current head of the presidential guard, June 27, 2013 for his alleged involvement in the massacre of the stadium on 28 September 2009. FIDH and OGDH worry that Mr. Claude PIVI and one of his co-defendants in the case of 28 September 2009, Lieutenant-Colonel Thiegboro CAMARA mandated to restore public order in Forest Guinea after clashes international community in the region Nzerekore that would have a hundred deaths. ”  Judicial advances in 2013 are to be commended for this declared by the President as the year of justice year, but send two security officials indicted justice for serious violations of human rights restore order in the province, it seems inappropriate  , “said Karim LAHIDJI, President of FIDH. ”  We ask that they be relieved of their duties until their responsibility for these criminal acts have been decided by a court, which can then decide with confidence  , “he added.



Amnesty International calls on the Guinean authorities to investigate reports that police used excessive force to quell election protests in the capital Conakry during the past week, leaving one person dead, about 60 injured and more than 100 detained.

Government forces intervened in demonstrations by supporters of rival political parties after the country’s presidential run-off was postponed for the third time on Friday. Security forces fired indiscriminately at unarmed civilians, beat protesters and ransacked homes.

“This ruthless and reckless reaction to the protests is the latest example of violence by Guinea’s security forces, whose brutality habitually goes unpunished,” said Gaëtan Mootoo, Amnesty International’s Guinea researcher.

“The authorities must investigate reports of torture and ill-treatment by its forces and charge or release all those detained, while ensuring that no more lives are claimed by the police’s heavy-handedness as the uncertainty over elections continues.”

Amnesty International understands that at least 15 people were shot by security forces. One person, Ibrahim Khalil Bangourah, is confirmed to have died as a result of his injuries.

Former prime minister Cellou Dalein Diallo, who took 43% of votes in the first round of the election in June, takes on opposition leader Alpha Condé, who won 18% of the vote, in the presidential run-off.

However, the final round of the election – set to be the country’s first democratic poll after 52 years of authoritarian rule – has now been delayed three times due to what the country’s electoral commission termed “technical difficulties”; reportedly a lack of voting facilities.

The latest cancellation sparked two days of clashes between followers of Conde and Diallo, although calm appeared to be restored by Sunday as a government ban on demonstrations was observed by party supporters.

Eyewitnesses told Amnesty International that police had undressed and beaten several protesters in clashes across Conakry.

“I was sitting and eating with my relatives when the security forces arrived in the yard, threw away the plates and beat us – three of us were taken to the police station,” one released detainee told Amnesty International.

Prominent human rights activist Aliou Barry, president of the Observatory for the Defence of Human Rights, was beaten after trying to speak out against the beatings of other protesters on Saturday.

Amnesty International has called for reform of Guinea’s security forces for years, especially since the “Bloody Monday” massacre of 28 September 2009. On that day and in the following days, security forces killed more than 150 people and raped more than 40 women during and following protests against the decision by the head of state, Dadis Camara, to stand in the presidential elections.

More than 1,500 people were wounded and many people went missing or were detained. Many perpetrators of the massacre remain in positions of authority, protected from prosecution.

Since 2004, arms or training have been provided to Guinea’s security forces from China, France, Germany, Mali, Morocco, Nigeria, South Africa and the USA.


Guinea: Ensure Restraint by Security Forces During Elections

Source: Human Rights Watch (HRW)

Date: 05 Nov 2010

(Dakar, November 5, 2010) – The special unit to maintain security during the second round of Guinea’s presidential elections, on November 7, 2010, should act with discipline, minimum force, and neutrality, Human Rights Watch said today. While the first round of elections took place in June in relative calm, the run-off election will take place amid heightened ethnic and political tensions.

In May, the Guinean government created the Special Force for a Safe Electoral Process (Force spéciale de sécurisation du processus électoral, FOSSEPEL), with 16,000 members, half of them police and half gendarmes, to ensure security during and after the electoral process. The few clashes between supporters of different political parties before and immediately after the first round were defused quickly and in apparent compliance with the principles of minimum use of force. However, FOSSEPEL officials’ response to political violence in late October in Conakry, the capital, was characterized by excessive force, lack of discipline, criminality, and ethnic partisanship.

“The chances for violence during, and particularly after, this election are very real,” said Corinne Dufka, senior West Africa researcher at Human Rights Watch. “The Guinean security services must do all they can to protect all Guineans and ensure that the electorate is able to cast their votes free of fear.”

General Ibrahim Baldé, the head of the National Gendarmerie, commands the special unit. In July, Baldé signed a much-needed Use of Force Policy, under which Guinean security forces are required to adhere to internationally recognized best practices for responding to violence, including minimum use of force.

During the October clashes, Human Rights Watch received numerous credible reports of misconduct by policemen and gendarmes serving with FOSSEPEL, including beatings and assaults on party supporters. In some cases, the victims were even chased into their homes and workplaces. Based on the reports, some members of the security unit used the unrest as a pretext to loot shops and commit criminal acts, including theft of mobile phones, money, and other goods.

Each of the two candidates for the run-off election is from one of the country’s two largest ethnic groups, and members of each group largely support the candidate from their own group. Cellou Dalein Diallo, of the Union of Democratic Forces of Guinea (Union des forces démocratiques de Guinée, UFDG), is a Peuhl; and Alpha Condé, Rally of the Guinean People Party (Rassemblement du peuple de Guinée, RPG), is a Malinké. Very few Peuhls are members of the security services, though.

Witnesses described how some FOSSEPEL officers targeted individuals for abuse and theft on the basis of their ethnicity, using racially motivated threats and warning them not to vote for a particular party. Scores of protesters were also arbitrarily detained in gendarme camps and denied access to legal representation.

After the unrest in October, the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) reported that at least one person had been killed and 62 injured by the security forces in what it determined was excessive use of force. Members of FOSSEPEL have been implicated in many of the recorded incidents. During some incidents, demonstrators erected roadblocks, burned tires, and threw stones, wounding some members of the security forces.

Instead of initiating investigations into allegations of abuse, FOSSEPEL officials appear to have distanced themselves from responsibility, Human Rights Watch said. Local news sources have reported that senior members of the security forces, including Baldé himself, said the alleged abuses were committed by “uncontrolled elements” within the police, gendarmes, and army.

Political and ethnic tension has been steadily rising in Guinea since September. The body charged with overseeing the election has only recently resolved a leadership crisis, while Guineans have waited through three postponements for the presidential election’s second round. A suspected poisoning of dozens of supporters of the Guinean People Party during a meeting in Conakry spurred ethnically motivated attacks against members of the Peuhl ethnicity in at least four towns. The violence displaced about several thousands of people, mostly from the eastern towns of Siguiri, Kouroussa, and Kissidougou.

The tension has led many diplomats, analysts, and civil society leaders to warn of the likelihood of political violence after the second round. Human Rights Watch urged the Guinean authorities, especially General Baldé, to:

– Direct all members of FOSSEPEL forces to abide by the UN Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials in policing demonstrations, and to frequently, and publicly, reinforce these instructions;

– Reiterate a zero-tolerance policy for criminal behavior and human rights abuses by the police and gendarmes; and

– Inform all ranks of the security forces that credible allegations of human rights abuses by security forces will be investigated and that those responsible will be disciplined and held to account.

The UN principles require law enforcement officials, in carrying out their duties, to use nonviolent means as far as possible before resorting to force. Whenever the lawful use of force is unavoidable, law enforcement officials must use restraint, minimize damage and injury at all times, and respect and preserve human life. Guinean authorities are responsible for ensuring that commanding officers are held accountable if they know, or had reason to know, that law enforcement officials under their command resorted to the unlawful use of force and firearms, and if they failed to take all measures in their power to prevent, suppress, or report such abuse.

Guinean security forces have on numerous occasions in the past used excessive and lethal force and engaged in widespread criminal activities in the course of responding to demonstrations. In 2006 and 2007, about 150 people were killed while protesting deteriorating economic conditions, and 1,700 were wounded. On September 28, 2009, at least 150 demonstrators were killed and 100 women and girls were raped by security forces during a bloody crackdown on demonstrators calling for free and fair elections.

Human Rights Watch also called on the United Nations, the European Union, France, and the United States to exert consistent and meaningful pressure on the security unit’s commanders and Guinea’s political leaders to ensure credible and peaceful elections.

“The second round of Guinea’s elections can be a turning point for people long denied the right to freely elect their president,” Dufka said. “If the security forces remain neutral, act professionally, and respond to any violence by making every effort to protect human life, they can help make this election a victory for all Guineans.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s